File under: “Milking it.”
Diehard fans might not think of NYC-based avant-garde jazz trio Medeski Martin & Wood as “formulaic,” but think about it this way: they’ve been around for almost 20 years, and despite a few notable stylistic revisions, the band has been at least somewhat avant-garde and experimental since their inception. The Radiolarians series, on the surface, sounds like no exception. However, the band attempt to justify the project by explaining that they came up with the songs, toured on them and let them naturally evolve, THEN recorded them, which is supposed to be fundamentally different from the typical recording process. Ooooh. Sounds that way.
Okay, I admit: some of the songs are a little more “organic” and freeform than their past efforts, but considering the nature of their music, that could have easily happened anyway. In fact, that whole first paragraph was probably way too harsh. MMW are some of the best performers I’ve ever had the pleasure of seeing, and their technical proficiency and vibe continues to impress me. Radiolarians 1 proves that they still have the grooves as well as the fire that makes them stand out. “Professor Nohair” is a throwback to their original acoustic piano trio roots, while “Reliquary” sees them exploring and branching off from the “electric Davis” sound with which they experimented on Louder Now, their 2nd collaboration with guitarist John Scofield. On “Fire God,” Billy Martin sounds more like a traditional jazz drummer than he ever has. Yet, as with most MMW releases, nothing gold can stay, and they often revert back to their amorphous, noisy, free-jazz-fusion and lose me within a minute or so. It is this flaw as well as the uneven pacing of the album that keeps Radiolarians 1 from making its intended impact as a write-tour-record album.
Overall: 6.5/10
